Showing posts with label L2E. Show all posts
Showing posts with label L2E. Show all posts

Sunday, January 16, 2011

Letter RE: "Technology outpaces Privacy (Yet Again)" -- NY TIMES

Ms. Singer suggests that we are again witnessing the continual conflict between technology and privacy protections. Ms. Singer is wrong. Things have changed, drastically. Rather than have our privacy taken away from us by new technologies, we are now actively giving it away (albeit often due to the not-so-subtle coaxing of the new technology companies --like camera companies encouraging exhibitionism). We twitter or post our most banal experiences and thoughts, or provide websites with intimate financial details and genomic predispositions.
Perhaps we need to first reassess our shifting perceptions of privacy before we look to our slow moving legislatures and even slower to evolve laws.

Dov Greenbaum, JD MPhil PhD
Mark Gerstein, PhD

Unpublished letter in response to
Natasha Singer's "Technology Outpaces Privacy (Yet Again)" (12/12/2010)
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/12/business/12stream.html

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Letter to the Editor RE: "Rare Hits and Heaps of Misses to Pay For" -- NY Times

Mr. Wade criticizes California for placing such a large bet on stem cell research at the potential expense of other research efforts. Government regulation and funding are, to some extent, tied to the public's understanding of science, including their misconceptions and/or misapprehensions. These errors in conventional wisdom are often fueled by instances of misrepresentation or unwarranted hyperbole in the news and entertainment media. The Science TImes however, and Wade in particular, more often than not reflect a more balanced science journalism. Rather than tout every preliminary result as a monumental breakthrough, as many of his colleagues might do, Mr. Wade has consistently tamped down the hype, particularly when reporting on stem cells. Perhaps with better communication between science and the media, and more journalists like Mr. Wade, we might have less egregious use of funds and better regulatory oversight of basic science research.

Dov Greenbaum JD PhD & Mark Gerstein, PhD


Unpublished letter in response to:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/11/09/science/09wade.html
"Rare Hits and Heaps of Misses to Pay For"
BY Nicholas Wade, November 9, 2010, New York Times

Letter RE: "Sergey Brin’s Search for a Parkinson’s Cure” -- Wired Magazine

Sergey Brin’s quest to find a cure for Parkinson’s disease represents the confluence of two relatively recent trends: the internet’s ability to create extraordinary wealth for young technically minded individuals, and the introduction of personal genomics and its potential to forecast future illnesses many decades in advance.

As a medical scientists we can attest to the substantial costs involved in collecting large amounts of high-quality data; Sergey’s attempt to develop large-scal
Publish Post
e datasets in his quest for a cure, at a comparatively low price, will be a boon to science. However, perhaps Parkinson’s disease is not the correct place to beta-test this new methodology for collecting large amounts of data.

Notwithstanding the obvious benefits to society, Sergey’s large-scale survey type of methodology might be better deployed initially on more innocuous ailments, such as headaches or the common cold. These and other less severe maladies have fewer external costs and repercussions: they do not require genetic counseling, obtaining informed consent is more straightforward, and the privacy issues are not as serious.

Dov Greenbaum, JD MPhil PhD
Mark Gerstein, PhD


Unpublished letter in response to:
“Sergey Brin’s Search for a Parkinson’s Cure”
http://www.wired.com/magazine/2010/06/ff_sergeys_search

BY Thomas Goetz
Features Section,
Issue 18.07
Published June 22, 2010
Wired Magazine

Sunday, November 14, 2010

Letter Re "The Web Means the End of Forgetting" -- NY Times

In “The Web Means the End of Forgetting,” Jeffery Rosen focuses on the emerging realization that it is nearly impossible to erase the information that we post about ourselves on the Internet. While the article focused on the obvious concerns, bits of information put on the Internet that in hindsight we regret posting --that drunken party picture, the problem is even more serious when we consider how the internet allows even comparatively innocuous information to more seriously compromise our privacy.

Imagine, for example, collecting the times of blog posts to learn someone’s free time schedule, or triangulating the coordinates of geotaged locations in an online photo gallery to get a sense of where someone lives. Technological advances in aggregating and mining large amounts of data coupled with robust statistical correlations can render even relatively benign facts revealing and actually prove as problematic as that persistent drunken party picture.

Dov Greenbaum, JD MPhil PhD
Mark Gerstein, PhD

Unpublished letter in response to:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/25/magazine/25privacy-t2.html
Jeffrey Rosen's "The Web Means the End of Forgetting," NY Times 7/19/2010

Friday, November 5, 2010

Letter Re: Berekley DTC Genomics -- USA Today

UC Berkeley's distribution of genetic tests to incoming freshmen follows recent industry scrutiny by the FDA and Congress. The current media focus on Direct-to-consumer genetic testing will foster a robust dialogue at Berkeley. However, while the genes tested are thought to be relatively innocuous, the results anonymous, and the test intended to be partially educational --preparing students for a personal-genomic future -- we fear it may be anything but. It may lull students into a false sense of security, both in the absoluteness of the results relationship to their lifestyle and the risk-free sharing of those results with friends. Unlike the genes tested by Berkeley, most gene-disease relationships are complex and couched in terms of complicated statistical probabilities Further, many of the student's future genetic tests will involve serious and potentially upsetting personal medical and health information that will affect not only themselves but family members that share their genes.

Dov Greenbaum & Mark Gerstein

Unpublished letter in response to various articles:
UC Berkeley plan to test freshmen DNA criticized, USA Today
(http://www.usatoday.com/news/health/2010-05-21-berkeley-dna_N.htm)
and
SF Chronicle, http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2010/05/20/BAIS1DI09I.DTL

Letter RE: “Web Photos That Reveal Secrets, Like Where You Live" -- NY TIMES

In “Web Photos That Reveal Secrets, Like Where You Live” Kate Murphy focuses on the use of geotags –encoded geographical coordinates in pictures – to find hidden personal information. Geotags, represent only one of many privacy concerns rising out of the use of social networking websites. With the emerging realization that it is nearly impossible to erase information that we post about ourselves on the Internet, and with technological advances and robust statistical correlations for aggregating and mining large amounts of data, even comparatively innocuous facts or pictures can seriously compromise our privacy.

Dov Greenbaum, JD PhD & Mark Gerstein, PhD

Unpublished letter in response to: 
Web Photos That Reveal Secrets, Like Where You Live"
By Kate Murphy
Published: August 11, 2010

Wednesday, November 3, 2010

Letter Re "Where Scott Brown Is Coming From" -- NY Times

I found the magazine article on the new Massachusetts senator Scott Brown highly entertaining. A comparison that immediately came to mind, which surprising wasn't mentioned in the article, was the Senator as an East Coast version of Arnold. The similarities are obvious: a moderate republican in a blue state, screen-worthy good looks and a widespread regular-guy appeal to Joe the plumber.

Mark Gerstein

Unpublished letter in response to:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/28/magazine/28Brown-t.html
Where Scott Brown Is Coming From
By FRANK BRUNI
Published: February 22, 2010
The New York Times

Letter Re "How Privacy Vanishes Online" -- NY Times

Steve Lohr's recent article on the privacy implications of data mining
social networks points out how social connections can be mined to find
out non-trivial and very private information. Taken to the
extreme we could imagine that a person's social connections or other
bits of information revealed
on-line could be correlated with other data and eventually lead to the
divulgence of "inappropriate" information: for instance, a seemingly benign stock
question might actually be perfectly correlated with say political
affiliation or sexual orientation. In the near future common
situations like job interviews may represent a moral minefield
in the nature and type of unintentional information disclosure.

Dov Greenbaum
Mark Gerstein

Unpublished letter in response to:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/17/technology/17privacy.html
How Privacy Vanishes Online
By STEVE LOHR
Published: March 16, 2010

Letter Re "In Bid to Sway Sales, Cameras Track Shoppers" -- NY Times

Ms. Rosenblum's recent article regarding the tracking of consumers by
store cameras represents only the latest blow to the erosion of
privacy in our culture. With the cost of genomic sequencing and
analysis plummeting one could imagine stores eventually tracking the
genes of their customers as well: collecting latent DNA on shopping
carts to determine how many of their customers are lactose intolerant,
potentially diabetic, or have a gluten intolerance, and stocking their
shelves appropriately.

One could even imagine correlating the genes with camera images to
give a simple form of gene association study.

A less benign example might include shopkeepers collecting, cataloging
and subsequently selling a host of genomic information to the highest
bidder.

Mark Gerstein
Dov Greenbaum

Unpublished letter in response to:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/20/business/20surveillance.html
Stephanie Rosenblum's 3/19/20 "In Bid to Sway Sales, Cameras Track Shoppers,"
NY Times

Letter Re "Google Says It Collected Private Data by Mistake" -- NY Times

We read with great interest Mr. Stone's article regarding Google's
admission that it inadvertently collected private data as part of its
Street View project in Europe. We disagree, however with the
article's condemning tone; Google should be commended for its efforts.
In an age of corporate cover-ups Google's actions stand out: it did
not try to collect private data, it publicly reported the
unintentional collection without prodding, and it is purging
information already collected. Moreover, the information collected
(random bits of unencrypted Internet traffic) is overtly less
problematic than the health or financial records that many already
unashamedly share online. The fact that Google itself was stymied in
dealing with this information underscores how difficult it is to
grapple with private data. It also highlights just how much
technological and legal effort we as a society will have to put into
safeguarding privacy.

Dov Greenbaum, JD MPhil PhD
Mark Gerstein, PhD

Unpublished letter in response to:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/15/business/15google.html
Brad Stone's "Google Says It Collected Private Data by Mistake,"
NY Times (5/14/2010)

Letter Re "Where’d You Go With My DNA?" -- NY Times

We read with great interest Ms. Harmon's Week In Review article about informed consent relating to DNA samples. One issue that the article hinted at, but did not directly address, was how technology has changed the game. Because of the rapid pace of DNA sequencing, it is now possible to read the entire genome of the individual from which a biological sample was taken. While a given sample may end up being used for a limitless number of different disease correlations and studies, this valuable information remains highly personal in nature: each unique sample from say, a diabetic patient, is fundamentally from -- and can be traced back to via the deciphered genetic sequence -- a unique individual. It can never be completely anonymized. This reality necessitates that we fundamentally rethink the entire issue of informed consent.
Dov Greenbaum, JD PhD
Mark Gerstein, PhD
Yale University

Unpublished letter
Letter to the Editor in response to
Amy Harmon's "‘Informed Consent’ and the Ethics of DNA Research"
NY Times, 4/25/2010
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/25/weekinreview/25harmon.html
Where’d You Go With My DNA?

Letter Re "Genesis redux" -- Economist

Craig Venter's recent success in developing a synthetic bacterial cell
is a promising proof of concept for Synthetic Biology. Of particular
interest might be the ability to develop affordable and eco-friendly
biofuels that rely on waste biomass or novel enzymes, instead of the
current biofuel supply supported by government subsidies and relying
mostly on the inefficient use of food crops. Venter's watermarking
and attempt to patent the new cell however, may raise concerns as to
ownership of novel synthetic biology tools. In contrast to other
clean energy sources --where public domain technology suffices in
providing clean energy -- the necessary synthetic biology technology
for feasible biofuels will likely be, like Venter's cell, someone's
intellectual property.
Dov Greenbaum & Mark Gerstein

Unpublished letter in response to:
http://www.economist.com/displaystory.cfm?story_id=16163006
Genesis redux, Economist, 20 May 2010

Letter RE "Scientists Create Synthetic Organism" -- WSJ

We were very intrigued to read about J. Craig Venter’s creation of an
artificial organism, an amazing technical feat that certainly deserves
a tremendous amount of praise. An interesting point mentioned briefly
at the end of the article is that Dr. Venter inscribed his name, a
little bit of poetry, and a few additional messages in this organism.
These inscriptions raise the possibility that small bacterial
organisms may become the information storage devices of the future.
Indeed, DNA is an ideal medium for storing information -- essentially,
this particular molecule has been selected by evolution for this very
purpose given that it is so stable and can be replicated with
error-correcting machinery. We can well imagine a future filled with
long-term storage of information taking the form of specially created
microorganisms synthesized with messages embedded within them.

Dov Greenbaum, JD MPhil PhD
Mark Gerstein, PhD

Unpublished letter in response to:
Robert Lee Hotz's "Scientists Create Synthetic Organism" WSJ, (5/21/2010)
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703559004575256470152341984.html

Letter Re "Supersizing Hits Freight World" -- WSJ

I read with great interest the recent article about the plan to use ever larger "green" trucks on highways. I was rather appalled by this proposal, as I think it will lead to even more inefficiencies and make driving on highways an even scarier experience than it already is. Just the other day I was trailed by a convoy of 18-wheelers that was overwhelmingly large and intimidating, and reminded me just how scary it is to share the road with imposing vehicles. If it is indeed inevitable that we are going to have larger and larger vehicles on the road, perhaps there should in turn be some concessions for motorists. I could imagine, for instance, a law mandating that truckers consistently drive at 50 mph and only in the right lane. This type of measure would likely save even more gas than the current proposal for ever larger trucks and lead to a win-win solution -- for everyone, that is, except, of course, a hard-charging truck driver.
Mark Gerstein
New Haven, CT

Unpublished letter in response to:
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704901104575423403671120166.html
Supersizing Hits Freight World
BY JENNIFER LEVITZ, WSJ, 15 Aug. 2010

Letter Re "The Pen That Never Forgets" -- NY Times

I read with great interest the recent article about the Livescribe pen. This is truly an innovative device; I doubt people could have anticipated it before its debut. Nevertheless, I see this as a transitional gadget. I anticipate that very shortly, practically at any moment, it will become trivially easy to discreetly record a full-length video of a class lecture or a business meeting and sync it with notes. Having video in addition to audio will, of course, not only make it much easier to follow what the instructor is writing on the blackboard or the client in a meeting, but will also help interpret subtleties in gestures, facial expressions, and statements. While I think this is in principle a good thing, we have to reflect soon on how seemingly trivial note-taking recordings will change the character of our classrooms and boardrooms. Perhaps people will be a little more reticent to put forth ideas when they know that everything they say is being filmed by a number of people. Perhaps this will be the impetus to change the culture of sharing that we see so much of now on the Internet when people realize that everything they say is being recorded in an almost Orwellian fashion.

Mark Gerstein

Unpublished letter in response to:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/09/19/magazine/19Livescribe-t.html
The Pen That Never Forgets
By CLIVE THOMPSON
Published: September 16, 2010

Monday, February 15, 2010

Letter Re "Discovering the Unseen Risks of Genetic Diseases" -- WSJ

Ms. Marcus's article raises real and relevant concerns for carriers of a small percentage of genetic diseases. Carriers of most genetic disorders, however, typically exhibit no symptoms and it's thought that many may actually achieve beneficial health externalities as a result of their carrier status.

Nevertheless the findings presented may lead to serious concerns in light of the emerging unregulated personal genomic industry that provides detailed genetic information to its customers. Without proper guidance and context, consumers of personal genomics products that now find themselves to be carriers of a disease might either become overly concerned regarding a benign carrier status, or alternatively, complacent in the face of some of the more detrimental carrier genes highlighted in her article.

Unpublished letter in response to:
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704160504574640621141065600.html
Discovering the Unseen Risks of Genetic Diseases
WSJ, Amy Marcus, 2/14/2010